Pralines For Christmas
Christmas Memories - Anderson County Tennessee

Away In A Manger

Steve and tipper 1970

Steve & Tipper Christmas 1970

Away In A Manger is the lullaby of Christmas songs. I've always thought the simple lines of the song make it sound like a folk song-and the visuals of stars, hay, cattle, and meeting in heaven help reinforce the folk song feeling. The fact that no one knows who wrote the song also aligns it with other folk songs from the same era.

For many years Martin Luther, Protestant Reformer from Germany, was credited with writing the song. No one knows why-but in 1887 James R. Murray published the song in his book Dainty Songs for Little Lads and Lasses-listing Luther as the writer of the song. Murray was a hymn writer and worked for a publishing company, so it's probable that he truly thought Luther was the person who penned Away In A Manger. The version of the song published in Murray's book only had 2 verses. During the years after the publication, the song spread in popularity-as did the notion that Luther wrote it.

Two years before Murray published the song, the Lutheran Church published Away In A Manger in a book- Little Children's Book-giving credit to no writer and showing a completely different tune than the one so many of us know and love. 

Shortly after WWI a Boston publishing company published the song crediting Carl Mueller with composing the music for the song. 

During both World Wars people in the US shied aways from singing Away In A Manger because of it's supposed connection to Martin Luther and Germany. But the popularity of the song returned after each war ended.

In 1945 American writer Richard Hill decided to unravel the confusing past of the song. Hill discovered Luther was not the writer of the song. Away In A Manger was practically unknown in Germany until it was introduced to the country by Americans. Hill verified that Murray composed the tune we are familiar with today. But Hill's research could not find the original writer of the song. Research did show evidence that most likely an American during the mid 1800s wrote the song and then it was passed down orally like so many of our other folk songs.  

Watch the video below to check out Pap and Paul's version of Away In A Manger.

(*Before you watch the video you need to stop the music player-the music controls are along the top of this page on the far left side-just under the Blind Pig logo. Click the center round button to stop the player.) *For those of you who have trouble viewing the video-go straight to youtube to see it by clicking here. In this video-Paul and Pap.

We are very grateful and humbled by all you folks who have purchased Pap and Paul's Songs of Christmas cds-THANK YOU! It really is packed with some of the best Christmas music I have ever heard. You can go here-Pap and Paul's Music to purchase a cd. Or if you live in the Murphy area email me and I'll tell you where you can find the cd. (email me at

And you can leave a comment on this post for a chance to win one of the cds.

*Giveaway ends Wednesday December 18 @ midnight.

Last Sunday's winner was:

#25 Wanda who said: The song was beautiful. Thanks for telling the story. Wanda send your address to me at and I'll send you a cd!


*Source: Collins, Ace. Stories behind the best-loved songs of Christmas. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Zondervan, 2001. Print.

Subscribe for free to Blind Pig And The Acorn by Email


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I hope nothing's wrong over at your
house. I had a 1/4" of snow this
morning. (not braggin' or anything!)
When I came in today about 2 pm, I
noticed the Blind Pig hadn't posted
any comments. Enjoyed Paul and Pap
singing "Away in a Manger" and all
the background information leading
up to the song. Thanks,...Ken

aww tipper that picture is so darling.. you are just as sweet today.. sending much love and happiness your way... enjoy the holiday season. isnt the Good Lord woderful with all the blessings he has given us ..
love the music.. and have been enjoying the cd of the boys... i think hubby is tired of hearing me trying to sing along.. (kinda like alfalfa )
big ladybug hugs

Thank you for a perfect version
of this beloved Christmas song.

I know, I know...I am "scrolling today" but I could not help but comment on the sweet picture at the tope of your post! What a beautiful littl baby girl you were! Steve looks so sweet there as well, holding on to his "slippery sliding sister!"
I sure remember those all aluminum Christmas trees..Did your Mom and Dads have a rotating color light wheel to go with it?
I have sold the wheels when I can find them! Also, the aluminum trees, too, they are scarce!
So many folks are collecting both.
The cat clock that it's tail swings while it eyes move to the tick tock is very pricy as well today. I finally found one for a customer a few years ago that just had to have one to put in his 50's 60's house decor.
Me...I'd rather have the sweet little children for my part!

I had never thought about the connection of Martin Luther and the War. It seems to me that I always knew the carol "Away In The Manger!" I know we sung it in elementary school..I started first grade at 5 in 1941...
I had read that the poem was written a long time before a melody was written, some time ago. It is a beautiful carol and one that is especially loved by chaperones when doing an reactment by the "creache" for the "Nativity".
"Away In The Manger" was my sons favorite song. Their childrens school Christmas chorus did and exceptional rendition of the song...of course I was prejudice...
Thanks Tipper,
PS...Back in the day when the milkman left milk at the door...the company would have the delivery man slip a small booklet with the milk. It was a sort of card from them for the season. It had all Christmas carols in it. Momma saved all of hers and now I have them, going into a scrapbook...It had the name of the company stamped on the back of the booklet. Always had a pretty Christmas scene on the the front of family, tree, angels etc. How many companies would dare to give out little Christmas Carol booklets today? I did get a card from my paper carrier...and a Calender from the insurance company for 2014...
PS Again, I have a big pot of "suet" rendoring on the stove. It is cold and I am in the bird food making mode! I have my pinecones ready and all the stuff I mix with the suet when it begins to cool....NOW HEAR THIS>>>Used to be you got "suet" the hard fat next to the beef kidney, FREE, nowadays we were shocked that the meat department charged us $1.00 lb. Seems when they get some on the beef that has to be cut off, they put in what they call the oil barrel! Will this be our car fuel???

I am really enjoying your articles relating to the history of our Christmas Carols. I always enjoyed listening/singing them, but never really knew many of their histories.

That was one of the first Christmas songs I learned as a child. A group of children taught me the song in Spanish several years ago. When I try to sing it now I tend to combine the two languages.

Playing the cd at work every day. Everybody loves it.

Whatever became of the cat clock up in the corner? Looks like it's about 9:35 AM.

Very interesting history on this Tipper and I love the song. Beautiful as always. It's one of my favorites.

Tipper: Now that is a precious photo of you two. I hope your SUNDAY MORNING IS AS NEAR PERFECT AS OUR MORNING!

We will once again listen to the SONGS OF CHRISTMAS as we enjoy a winter breakfast!

Season's Greetings,
Eva Nell

The song was great as usual Tipper. Enjoyed the history of the song.

If a picture is worth a thousand words, that little boy spoke volumes with that hug he was giving his little sister! Our family was kind of like yours, my older brother, myself, and our baby sister. That picture was worth a thousand words! Steve was serving notice, "This is MY baby sister!"

I like these posts about song history...esp when linked to a great version of the song. Thx

I agree with you, both versions have a folk song sound to them. does the one in the Lutheran hymnal have a melody similar to (with first phrase the same as) "Flow Gently Sweet Afton"? That's the only other "common" version I've learned.

And there are two quite different tunes that I have heard sung for this song - isn't that amazing??

Tipper, this is just beautiful! Couldn't help but lend this old alto voice to the blend of soprano and tenor. Next time we come to Sylva, think I will come on'a your house and sing a little harmony with the boys. Hmm... ...maybe bring my keyboard along. :) happy baking, shopping, decorating and wrapping--in that order--and keep it merry!

That is a precious picture, Tipper. Even then you looked like an angel.
The song is beautiful and fit for a baby angel or a baby son of god.

sweetness, peaceful, reverent, wonderfully done.

Thanks for sharing the story behind "Away in a Manger." Probably many, as I, thought Luther was the author of the words. And thanks, too, for allowing us to hear Pap and Paul's rendition of it! I enjoy their music so much! Wherever we are, and whatever Christmas carol is coursing through our minds or coming from our lips, may the songs afford us pleasure, insight and inspiration at this holy season. Christmas is "Emmanuel"--God with us!

Another favorite, I guess I am partial to all of them.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)